19 January, 2022

Book Endings We’d Like to Change

My Name is Asher Lev
By Chaim Potok

Artistically, you can’t trade this ending for anything in the world. When Asher Lev — a young Chasidic Jew with a preternatural gift for painting — finally presents his masterpiece, “Brooklyn Crucifixion,” the collective alienation felt by his devoutly religious family and community forces him to leave home for good. But emotionally, I always can’t help but wish that the dividing line here — between tradition and liberated individuality — had been possible to make disappear. The ultimate rejection of Lev by his own people cements Potok’s portrayal of this conflict; and, while he does it beautifully and timelessly, I dream of an ending in which personal love and creative freedom win out over the pressure of steadfast orthodoxy.
-Sam Spokony

3 thoughts on “Book Endings We’d Like to Change

  1. I think that for me, it would be The Time Traveler's Wife. In case someone hasn't read it, I won't say what I would change…but I suspect most who've read it know what I would change.

  2. I would change that one too, aliceisforever.
    And I totally agree with "IT". I was GLUED to that book (except that night a friend decided to raise a balloon right outside my bedroom window) and when I came to the end, I was poised for something equally dramatic and spellbinding and I got — a spider???? Pah-lu-heeze.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.