for the love of all things wordy

Home /
Category: LitStack Recs

Category: LitStack Recs

The Good Soldier, by Ford Madox Ford

If this novel had been published under the title the author selected, The Saddest Story, contemporary readers might have had a difficult time locating a copy. Fortunately, Ford Madox Ford agreed to his publisher’s title suggestion of The Good Soldier, and with that, the now-classic post-World War I novel of malaise and moral questioning came to be.

Published in 1915, the novel concerns two couples, one American and one English. On holiday in Europe in the summer of 1904, two well-off Americans, John and Florence Dowell, meet Captain Edward Ashburnham and his wife, Leonora, in Nauheim, Germany. John Dowell, the novel’s narrator, relates the story retrospectively, beginning at the famous first line, “This is the saddest story I’ve ever heard,” and a sad story it is, centering on serial infidelity, madness, and suicide. At a spa in Nauheim, Edward is being treated for what he claims is a heart ailment (“too much hard sportsmanship in his youth”). One afternoon, the couples go on an outing to see the museum of Protestant founder Martin Luther. Soon after, Florence and Edward begin an affair, though as Dowell explains, Florence’s aim, “to educate the whole lot of us,” soon meets with Leonora’s Catholicism—a factor that prevents a divorce from Edward.

The Good Soldier is built around more than one love triangle. Edward Ashburnham is unhappy in his arranged marriage with the strong-willed and strictly Catholic Leonora (they have not spoken to other in private for thirteen years). He is in fact a serial seducer, and Dowell’s story relates several affairs between Edward and vulnerable young women. Then there is Nancy Dufford, Leonora’s ward, whose liaison with Edward complicates an already-complex situation, since by then she’s been noticed by Dowell too: “She had a tortured mouth, agonised eyes, and a quite extraordinary sense of fun.”

In his role as narrator, Dowell’s voice has an uncertain tone, but it’s balanced by an instinct to explore, to revisit, and reconsider events—beginning with Florence’s affair with Edward, along with those that lead up to it, and those that follow. As Jane Smiley writes of Dowell’s voice, he “freely offers his own self-doubts about his competence, both as an actor in the drama and as an interpreter, and he manages not to seem either untruthful or self-serving.” Dowell’s disclosures and opinions have an insight tinged by doubt, a quality that recalls another narrator by another Ford, Richard Ford’s Frank Bascom. Like John Dowell, Bascom has a disarming forthrightness that turns unreliable. The pieces never quite add up, and it forms a quality that makes a character unforgettable.

Ford Madox Ford during WW1.

The Good Soldier is filled with bad hearts, weak hearts, hearts that are damaged, literally and figuratively. Florence feigns a bad heart to conduct an affair stateside with a dubious character named Jimmie, and commits suicide when she learns that Edward has begun an affair with Nancy. No one, in this novel, comes near to what they want, and if they do, there is disappointment, and circumstances shift the driving hopes. Near the book’s conclusion, Dowell poses a question central to the characters and their story:

Why can’t people have what they want? The things were all there to content everybody; yet everybody has the wrong thing.

In the end, Edward and Nancy are driven apart, though I’m not giving anything away, since plot isn’t the point of the book. The Good Soldier is widely considered to be the first modern novel, in its non-linear telling and subject of unraveling marriages. Events are presented, then circle back to be shown again with deepening layers of complexity. The modernity of the novel is in its form, and in its portrayal of collapse—between people, of customs and religion, and of the self in the aftermath of a brutal war, one that dismantles long held societal roles. The Good Soldier is a kind of anti-love story in which its characters, for reasons that run from madness to weakness to stringent piety, are denied love.

As Leonora says after the fateful outing to Nauheim: “Oh, where are all the bright, happy, innocent beings in the world? Where’s happiness? One reads of it in books!”

—Lauren Alwan

Pages: 1 2

LitStack Rec: Desperate Characters & The Last Days of Magic

Desperate Characters, by Paula Fox This classic of literary fiction, first published in 1970, serves too as a classic example of a novel that was lost to readers, then found. In 1999, when this—and all Paula Fox’s adult novels—fell out of print, interest in the author and her work was almost single-handedly revived by Jonathan […]


LitStack Recs: Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History & Blue Nights

Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History, by Stephen Jay Gould A book about the 1909 discovery of fossilized prehistoric multi-celled creatures in a rocky outcrop in the Canadian mountains?  Really?  That’s what’s being recommended? Really.  Completely and utterly, yes. Stephen Jay Gould was a brilliant paleontologist and evolutionary biologist, a skilled […]


LitStack Rec: Commonwealth & All the Birds in the Sky

Commonwealth, by Ann Patchett Of divorce, Nicole Krauss wrote, “One of us held on to the ambition of the one idea far longer than was reasonable, whereas the other, passing a garbage can one night, had casually thrown it away.” That’s how ending a marriage can feel, especially for the spouse who’s left behind, an […]


LitStack Rec: The Portable Veblen & Wait Till Next Year

The Portable Veblen, by Elizabeth McKenzie By way of Anne Lamott, we know the novelist Ethan Canin once remarked, “Nothing holds a story together better than a likable narrator.” Lamott went further (in the slim but influential memoir of writing, Bird by Bird), that a likable narrator is comparable to someone you love spending time […]


LitStack Rec: Stoner & Cradle to the Stage

Stoner, by John Williams John Williams’ 1965 novel went out of print after selling only 2,000 copies, but since its re-release by Vintage in 1995, this novel of a Midwestern academic’s insular life has appeared on bestseller lists in Europe and Israel, and has since sold over 100,000 copies. Stoner seems at first an unlikely […]


LitStack Rec: Central Station & Green Thoughts

Central Station by Lavie Tidhar It’s kind of hard to describe Lavie Tidhar’s Locus- nominated, Clarke-shortlisted book Central Station. It’s definitely science fiction. Absolutely futuristic. Sometimes surreal and sometimes quite practical. But it’s also decidedly unique, a touch bizarre, evidencing a future Earth that is both believable and terrifying in its nonchalance. Central Station, rising […]


LitStack Recs: Passage to Ararat & War for the Oaks

Passage to Ararat, by Michael J. Arlen “It’s a dangerous business,” writes Clark Blaise in this book’s introduction, “going into the underworld of history and ethnicity to discover one’s father, yet it seems one peculiar duty in our time of identity politics.” The observation is an apt one in which to begin Michael J. Arlen’s […]


LitStaff Recs: The Empathy Exams & Three Parts Dead

The Empathy Exams: Essays, by Leslie Jamison The Empathy Exams blends memoir, literary, cultural and moral investigation, and its essays are rich, astute, and candid. This is Jamison’s second book (following a 2011 novel The Gin Closet), winner of the Graywolf Press Nonfiction Prize that went on to the New York Times bestseller list. Jamison […]


LitStack Recs: Books About Actors and Film & Ancillary Justice

As the summer film season approaches, here are three books—a memoir, a novel, and a book-length interview—that offer a look behind the camera. Spielberg, Truffaut and Me: An Actor’s Diary, by Bob Balaban Spielberg, Truffaut and Me: An Actor’s Diary was published in 2002, and it’s a fascinating look behind the curtain of how the […]